Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
post
Last Updated on: 17 November, 2024
Author: Getaka|Social: Getaka Financial Services X (Earlier Twitter) Profile Getaka Financial Services LinkedIn Logo

Malu Paper Mills Ltd: Intrinsic Value and Fundamental Analysis

Share Price and Basic Stock Data

Last Updated: November 15, 2024, 2:32 pm

Market Cap 76.2 Cr.
Current Price 44.7
High / Low69.9/34.0
Stock P/E
Book Value 0.56
Dividend Yield0.00 %
ROCE9.24 %
ROE13.7 %
Face Value 10.0
PEG Ratio0.00

Stock P/E, Current Price, and Intrinsic Value Over Time

View Share Price Target for Malu Paper Mills Ltd

Competitors of Malu Paper Mills Ltd

Stock NameMarket CapCurrent PriceHigh / LowStock P/EBook ValueDividend YieldROCEROEFace Value
Gratex Industries Ltd 6.98 Cr. 23.026.0/13.0116 11.60.00 %4.54 %3.18 % 10.0
Ganga Papers India Ltd 119 Cr. 110191/74.776.6 27.60.00 %6.93 %5.22 % 10.0
Encode Packaging India Ltd 4.35 Cr. 13.818.7/6.6562.1 10.40.00 %3.24 %3.65 % 10.0
Cella Space Ltd 32.2 Cr. 16.016.7/7.9034.6 10.30.00 %10.7 %% 10.0
Bandaram Pharma Packtech Ltd 51.9 Cr. 43.263.1/28.331.6 11.00.23 %9.10 %6.77 % 10.0
Industry Average2,972.35 Cr226.1947.96139.520.83%26.26%12.72%6.60

All Competitor Stocks of Malu Paper Mills Ltd

Quarterly Result

MonthDec 2020Mar 2021Jun 2021Sep 2021Dec 2021Mar 2022Jun 2022Sep 2022Dec 2022Mar 2023Jun 2023Sep 2023Dec 2023
Sales46.0165.0634.5044.2556.4877.7563.3465.4347.4158.3770.0068.1561.51
Expenses42.9359.7635.4844.6655.5372.6359.8469.5749.5155.9465.8664.0457.20
Operating Profit3.085.30-0.98-0.410.955.123.50-4.14-2.102.434.144.114.31
OPM %6.69%8.15%-2.84%-0.93%1.68%6.59%5.53%-6.33%-4.43%4.16%5.91%6.03%7.01%
Other Income0.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.00
Interest1.782.201.721.801.792.602.042.092.062.452.582.622.58
Depreciation1.261.231.221.221.311.311.251.261.261.251.251.251.25
Profit before tax0.041.87-3.92-3.43-2.151.210.21-7.49-5.42-1.270.310.240.48
Tax %4,425.00%28.88%24.74%25.07%26.51%31.40%9.52%26.03%26.01%15.75%16.13%25.00%27.08%
Net Profit-1.741.34-2.94-2.57-1.580.830.18-5.55-4.02-1.080.260.170.36
EPS in Rs-1.020.79-1.72-1.51-0.930.490.11-3.25-2.36-0.630.150.100.21

Last Updated: Unknown

Quarterly Chart

Profit & Loss - Annual Report

Last Updated: Unknown

MonthMar 2012Mar 2013Mar 2014Mar 2015Mar 2016Mar 2017Mar 2018Mar 2019Mar 2020Mar 2021Mar 2022Mar 2023TTM
Sales164178211224221243279274226170212234258
Expenses174177189201200220261251213164208235243
Operating Profit-1012223212218231364-115
OPM %-6%1%10%10%9%9%6%9%6%3%2%-0%6%
Other Income0320211111110
Interest1415151616141210888910
Depreciation6665555555555
Profit before tax-29-1823342101-6-8-14-0
Tax %31%31%31%31%31%31%32%26%39%6%24%25%
Net Profit-20-121223171-6-6-10-0
EPS in Rs-11.85-7.280.821.101.141.690.864.350.39-3.38-3.67-6.13-0.17
Dividend Payout %0%0%0%0%0%0%0%0%0%0%0%0%

Profit & Loss Yearly Chart

YoY Net Profit Growth

Year2012-20132013-20142014-20152015-20162016-20172017-20182018-20192019-20202020-20212021-20222022-2023
YoY Net Profit Growth (%)40.00%108.33%100.00%0.00%50.00%-66.67%600.00%-85.71%-700.00%0.00%-66.67%
Change in YoY Net Profit Growth (%)0.00%68.33%-8.33%-100.00%50.00%-116.67%666.67%-685.71%-614.29%700.00%-66.67%

Malu Paper Mills Ltd has shown an inconsistent trend in YoY Net Profit Growth (%) in the last 11 years from 2012-2013 to 2022-2023.

Growth

Compounded Sales Growth
10 Years:3%
5 Years:0%
3 Years:17%
TTM:6%
Compounded Profit Growth
10 Years:-4%
5 Years:-34%
3 Years:29%
TTM:-11%
Stock Price CAGR
10 Years:15%
5 Years:15%
3 Years:10%
1 Year:17%
Return on Equity
10 Years:-3%
5 Years:-21%
3 Years:-40%
Last Year:14%

Last Updated: Unknown

Balance Sheet

Last Updated: November 14, 2024, 8:34 pm

MonthMar 2013Mar 2014Mar 2015Mar 2016Mar 2017Mar 2018Mar 2019Mar 2020Mar 2021Mar 2022Mar 2023Mar 2024Sep 2024
Equity Capital17171717171717171717171717
Reserves-7-6-4-277141470-11-10-16
Borrowings110110111108110101898893104123132138
Other Liabilities33323433183421223334222935
Total Liabilities153153157156152159140140151155151167174
Fixed Assets99939289848079807671686569
CWIP0000011000050
Investments0000000000000
Other Assets546065666777606074848397105
Total Assets153153157156152159140140151155151167174

Reserves and Borrowings Chart

Cash Flow

MonthMar 2013Mar 2014Mar 2015Mar 2016Mar 2017Mar 2018Mar 2019Mar 2020Mar 2021Mar 2022Mar 2023Mar 2024
Cash from Operating Activity +14141920201919154-2-99
Cash from Investing Activity +-2-0-3-213-4-4-10-2-8
Cash from Financing Activity +-11-14-16-19-22-22-16-11-2211-2
Net Cash Flow1-100-0-0-11-00-00

Free Cash Flow

MonthMar 2012Mar 2013Mar 2014Mar 2015Mar 2016Mar 2017Mar 2018Mar 2019Mar 2020Mar 2021Mar 2022Mar 2023
Free Cash Flow-10.00-109.00-88.00-88.00-87.00-88.00-83.00-66.00-75.00-87.00-100.00-124.00

Free Cash Flow = Income Generated from Operational Activities - Borrowings - Capital Work in Progress (CWIP)

Consistent positive free cash flow is crucial for businesses as it indicates their ability to generate cash from their core operations. It provides financial flexibility, allowing companies to invest in growth opportunities, pay dividends to shareholders, reduce debt, and weather economic downturns more effectively.

Free Cash Flow Chart

Financial Efficiency Indicators

MonthMar 2013Mar 2014Mar 2015Mar 2016Mar 2017Mar 2018Mar 2019Mar 2020Mar 2021Mar 2022Mar 2023Mar 2024
Debtor Days363635383536324270513541
Inventory Days38375049576261621019990108
Days Payable5843444242644458115774355
Cash Conversion Cycle163040455034494656738294
Working Capital Days183135404033405072697574
ROCE %-2%14%15%15%15%11%16%8%1%-0%-4%9%

Financial Efficiency Indicators Chart

Share Holding Pattern

MonthSep 2021Dec 2021Mar 2022Jun 2022Sep 2022Dec 2022Mar 2023Jun 2023Sep 2023Dec 2023Mar 2024Jun 2024
Promoters69.95%69.95%69.95%69.95%69.69%69.95%69.95%69.95%69.95%69.95%69.95%69.95%
Public30.05%30.05%30.05%30.05%30.30%30.05%30.06%30.06%30.05%30.06%30.05%30.06%
No. of Shareholders7,6827,5067,6237,7037,8848,0617,9337,8398,0218,1849,5199,330

Shareholding Pattern Chart

No. of Shareholders

This stock is not held by any mutual fund

ROCE Trend

EPS Trend

Key Financial Ratios

MonthMar 24Mar 23Mar 22Mar 21Mar 20
FaceValue10.0010.0010.0010.0010.00
Basic EPS (Rs.)0.54-6.07-3.61-3.440.39
Diluted EPS (Rs.)0.54-6.07-3.61-3.440.39
Cash EPS (Rs.)3.46-3.18-0.70-0.443.26
Book Value[Excl.RevalReserv]/Share (Rs.)3.983.7310.1114.1118.04
Book Value[Incl.RevalReserv]/Share (Rs.)3.983.7310.1114.1118.04
Revenue From Operations / Share (Rs.)160.87137.10124.2299.50132.67
PBDIT / Share (Rs.)10.18-0.192.743.928.15
PBIT / Share (Rs.)7.25-3.14-0.220.975.28
PBT / Share (Rs.)0.86-8.20-4.86-3.580.63
Net Profit / Share (Rs.)0.52-6.13-3.67-3.380.38
PBDIT Margin (%)6.33-0.132.203.936.14
PBIT Margin (%)4.50-2.28-0.180.983.97
PBT Margin (%)0.53-5.98-3.91-3.600.47
Net Profit Margin (%)0.32-4.46-2.95-3.390.29
Return on Networth / Equity (%)13.17-164.33-36.30-23.972.14
Return on Capital Employeed (%)60.40-26.17-1.615.2623.02
Return On Assets (%)0.53-6.92-4.02-3.820.47
Long Term Debt / Equity (X)1.842.050.310.270.24
Total Debt / Equity (X)19.3019.185.953.832.82
Asset Turnover Ratio (%)1.721.531.381.171.61
Current Ratio (X)0.580.540.570.570.53
Quick Ratio (X)0.240.230.250.330.32
Inventory Turnover Ratio (X)4.023.924.454.255.49
Interest Coverage Ratio (X)1.60-0.030.590.851.75
Interest Coverage Ratio (Post Tax) (X)1.08-0.210.200.251.08
Enterprise Value (Cr.)191.42168.26160.25135.62123.15
EV / Net Operating Revenue (X)0.690.710.750.790.54
EV / EBITDA (X)11.02-515.8234.2220.308.86
MarketCap / Net Operating Revenue (X)0.220.200.280.260.16
Price / BV (X)9.157.563.441.861.24
Price / Net Operating Revenue (X)0.220.200.280.260.16
EarningsYield0.01-0.21-0.10-0.120.01

Profitability Ratios (%)

Liquidity Ratios

Liquidity Ratios (%)

Interest Coverage Ratios (%)

Valuation Ratios

Fair Value

Fair Value of Malu Paper Mills Ltd as of November 17, 2024 is: 1.17

Calculation basis:

  • Fair value = P/E Ratio * (Return on Equity / 100) * Book Value * (1 + Dividend Yield / 100)
  • P/E Ratio (Price-to-Earnings Ratio): Represents the price of the stock relative to its earnings per share. A higher P/E ratio indicates that investors are willing to pay a higher price for the stock.
  • Return on Equity (ROE): Measures a company's profitability relative to its shareholder equity. It showcases the company's ability to generate profits using the investment made by its shareholders, offering valuable insight into its operational efficiency and financial performance.
  • Book Value: Represents the net asset value of the company per share. It is calculated as the total assets minus intangible assets and liabilities, divided by the number of outstanding shares.
  • Dividend Yield: The ratio of the annual dividend per share to the current market price per share. It offers valuable insights into the profitability of an investment through dividends.

This formula allows us to gauge the fair value of the stock by analyzing its fundamental indicators.

As of November 17, 2024, Malu Paper Mills Ltd is Overvalued by 97.38% compared to the current share price 44.70

Default values used*: Default value of 15 for Stock P/E is used

Intrinsic Value of Malu Paper Mills Ltd as of November 17, 2024 is: 1.07

Calculation basis:

  • Intrinsic value = P/E Ratio * (Return on Equity / 100) * Book Value * (1 + Dividend Yield / 100) * (1 + EPS CAGR for Last 5 Years)
  • P/E Ratio (Price-to-Earnings Ratio): Represents the price of the stock relative to its earnings per share. A higher P/E ratio indicates that investors are willing to pay a higher price for the stock.
  • Return on Equity (ROE): Measures a company's profitability relative to its shareholder equity. It showcases the company's ability to generate profits using the investment made by its shareholders, offering valuable insight into its operational efficiency and financial performance.
  • Book Value: Represents the net asset value of the company per share. It is calculated as the total assets minus intangible assets and liabilities, divided by the number of outstanding shares.
  • Dividend Yield: The ratio of the annual dividend per share to the current market price per share. It offers valuable insights into the profitability of an investment through dividends.
  • EPS CAGR (Compound Annual Growth Rate): Represents the geometric mean growth rate of earnings per share over the last 5 years. It provides insight into the historical growth trajectory of the company's earnings.

This formula allows us to gauge the intrinsic value of the stock by analyzing its fundamental indicators along with EPS growth.

As of November 17, 2024, Malu Paper Mills Ltd is Overvalued by 97.61% compared to the current share price 44.70

Default values used*: Default value of 15 for Stock P/E is used

Last 5 Year EPS CAGR: -8.51%

*Investments are subject to market risks

Strength and Weakness

StrengthWeakness
    1. The stock has a low average ROCE of 8.17%, which may not be favorable.
    2. The stock has a high average Working Capital Days of 48.08, which may not be favorable.
    3. The stock has a high average Cash Conversion Cycle of 51.25, which may not be favorable.
    4. The company has higher borrowings (109.00) compared to reserves (-0.54), which may suggest financial risk.
    5. The company has not shown consistent growth in sales (222.62) and profit (-3.85).

    Stock Analysis

    • Considering all of the following key financial indicators, prospective investors are encouraged to conduct thorough research and seek professional guidance before considering any investment in Malu Paper Mills Ltd:
      1. Net Profit Margin: 0.32%
        • Net Profit Margin: This metric indicates the percentage of profit a company makes from its total revenue. A higher net profit margin is generally desirable as it reflects better profitability.
      2. ROCE: 60.4% (Industry Average ROCE: 26.26%)
        • ROCE (Return on Capital Employed): ROCE measures a company's profitability and the efficiency with which its capital is employed. A higher ROCE indicates efficient use of capital.
      3. ROE%: 13.17% (Industry Average ROE: 12.72%)
        • ROE (Return on Equity): ROE measures a company's profitability relative to shareholders' equity. A higher ROE indicates efficient use of shareholders' funds.
      4. Interest Coverage Ratio (Post Tax): 1.08
        • Interest Coverage Ratio: The interest coverage ratio measures a company's ability to cover its interest payments on outstanding debt. A ratio greater than 2 is generally considered healthy as it indicates the company can meet its interest obligations comfortably.
      5. Quick Ratio: 0.24
        • Quick Ratio: The quick ratio assesses a company's ability to cover its short-term liabilities with its most liquid assets. A ratio higher than 1 suggests the company can meet its short-term obligations without relying heavily on inventory.
      6. Stock P/E: 0 (Industry average Stock P/E: 47.96)
        • Stock P/E (Price-to-Earnings) Ratio: The P/E ratio compares a company's current share price to its earnings per share. A lower P/E ratio relative to industry peers or historical values may indicate that the stock is undervalued.
      7. Total Debt / Equity: 19.3
        • Total Debt / Equity: This ratio measures a company's financial leverage by comparing its total debt to its total equity. A lower ratio indicates lower financial risk and greater financial stability.
      The current analysis is available for review. It's important to conduct thorough research and consider consulting with financial professionals before making any investment decisions.
      Stock Rating:

    About the Company - Qualitative Analysis

    Malu Paper Mills Ltd. is a Public Limited Listed company incorporated on 11/01/1994 and has its registered office in the State of Maharashtra, India. Company’s Corporate Identification Number(CIN) is L15142MH1994PLC076009 and registration number is 076009. Currently company belongs to the Industry of Paper & Paper Products. Company’s Total Operating Revenue is Rs. 211.91 Cr. and Equity Capital is Rs. 17.06 Cr. for the Year ended 31/03/2022.
    INDUSTRYADDRESSCONTACT
    Paper & Paper ProductsHeera Plaza, 4th Floor, Near Telephone Exchange, Nagpur Maharashtra 440008info@malupaper.com
    http://www.malupaper.com
    Management
    NamePosition Held
    Mr. Punamchand MaluManaging Director & CEO
    Mr. Banwarilal MaluJoint Managing Director
    Mr. Purushottam MaluNon Executive Director
    Mr. Vasudeo MaluNon Executive Director
    Mr. Satyanarayan RathiIndependent Director
    CA. Sahil AgrawalIndependent Director
    CA. Shrutika InaniIndependent Director
    Mr. Chandrakant ThakarIndependent Director

    FAQ

    What is the latest intrinsic value of Malu Paper Mills Ltd?

    The latest intrinsic value of Malu Paper Mills Ltd as on 17 November 2024 is ₹1.17, which is 97.38% lower than the current market price of ₹44.70.

    What is the Market Cap of Malu Paper Mills Ltd?

    The Market Cap of Malu Paper Mills Ltd is 76.2 Cr..

    What is the current Stock Price of Malu Paper Mills Ltd as on 17 November 2024?

    The current stock price of Malu Paper Mills Ltd as on 17 November 2024 is ₹44.7.

    What is the High / Low of Malu Paper Mills Ltd stocks in FY 2024?

    In FY 2024, the High / Low of Malu Paper Mills Ltd stocks is 69.9/34.0.

    What is the Stock P/E of Malu Paper Mills Ltd?

    The Stock P/E of Malu Paper Mills Ltd is .

    What is the Book Value of Malu Paper Mills Ltd?

    The Book Value of Malu Paper Mills Ltd is 0.56.

    What is the Dividend Yield of Malu Paper Mills Ltd?

    The Dividend Yield of Malu Paper Mills Ltd is 0.00 %.

    What is the ROCE of Malu Paper Mills Ltd?

    The ROCE of Malu Paper Mills Ltd is 9.24 %.

    What is the ROE of Malu Paper Mills Ltd?

    The ROE of Malu Paper Mills Ltd is 13.7 %.

    What is the Face Value of Malu Paper Mills Ltd?

    The Face Value of Malu Paper Mills Ltd is 10.0.

    About the Author

    Author Avatar
    Getaka

    Getaka, CFA, a financial analyst with 15 years of experience in the industry. Getaka holds an MBA degree and the Chartered Financial Analyst designation, demonstrating his profound understanding of financial analysis and investment management. Throughout his career, he has conducted numerous financial analyses and due diligence processes for companies in the industry, and has a strong track record of identifying key trends and opportunities. He leverages his expertise to deliver a thorough financial analysis of a company, encompassing its financial performance, key ratios, future prospects, and risks. Getaka is committed to providing accurate, reliable, and trustworthy information to help readers make informed decisions about their finances and investments.

    Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial advice. The author is not a SEBI registered financial advisor and does not have any vested interest in Malu Paper Mills Ltd. Investors are advised to conduct their own due diligence and consult with a financial professional before making any investment decisions. The information provided in this article is based on publicly available data and the author's analysis, but it may not be comprehensive or up-to-date. The author and getaka.co.in are not responsible for any errors or omissions in the content. This article is not intended to promote any particular investment strategy or recommendation, and readers should consult with their own financial advisors before making any investment decisions. Data Source: NSE